Hacker News

XOR’ing a register with itself is the idiom for zeroing it out. Why not sub?

ShowCover

Matt Godbolt, probably best known for being the proprietor of Compiler Explorer, wrote a brief article on why x86 compilers love the xor eax, eax instruction. The answer is that it is the most compact way to set a register to zero on x86. In particular, it is several bytes shorter than the more obvious mov eax, 0 since it avoids having to encode the four-byte constant. The x86 architecture does not have a dedicated zero register, so if you need to zero out a register, you’ll have to do it ab initio. But Matt doesn’t explain why everyone chooses xor as opposed to some other mathematical operation that is guaranteed to result in a zero? In particular, what’s wrong with sub eax, eax? It encodes to the same number of bytes, executes in the same number of cycles. And its behavior with…

Continue reading at Hacker News devblogs.microsoft.com
Advertisement