Why “AI should always TDD” is half-right, and what senior engineers actually do instead. A thesis is making the rounds in 2026: AI-assisted coding without tests is dangerous slop generation, therefore every prompt should be wrapped in a Red-Green-Refactor loop. The conclusion is correct. The reasoning is half wrong. And acting on the half-wrong reasoning produces slightly-better slop, faster. Test-Driven Development was designed in 2003 for a world where the spec already lived in the developer’s head and tests externalized it. That world had two properties LLM development does not: outputs were deterministic, and the cost of writing a test was negligible compared to writing the implementation. Both assumptions break in the AI era, but not in the same way for every kind of AI work….
Context Beats Tests: An Engineering Discipline for the LLM Era
Advertisement